Ballot Results
Comment: View Comment Results
Ballot Name:
Technical Rationale for Reliability Standards VAR-501-WECC-3.1 Non-Binding Poll IN 1 NB
Voting Start Date:
4/10/2020 12:01:00 AM
Voting End Date:
4/20/2020 8:00:00 PM
Ballot Type:
NB
Ballot Activity:
IN
Ballot Series:
1
Total # Votes:
161
Total Ballot Pool:
195
Quorum:
82.56
Quorum Established Date:
4/20/2020 4:55:47 PM
Weighted Segment Value:
79.25
Segment | Ballot Pool | Segment Weight | Affirmative Votes | Affirmative Fraction | Negative Votes | Negative Fraction | Abstain | No Vote |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Segment: 1 | 47 | 1 | 22 | 0.815 | 5 | 0.185 | 16 | 4 |
Segment: 2 | 5 | 0.3 | 3 | 0.3 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 0 |
Segment: 3 | 42 | 1 | 17 | 0.773 | 5 | 0.227 | 12 | 8 |
Segment: 4 | 12 | 0.6 | 4 | 0.4 | 2 | 0.2 | 3 | 3 |
Segment: 5 | 46 | 1 | 19 | 0.792 | 5 | 0.208 | 12 | 10 |
Segment: 6 | 35 | 1 | 15 | 0.75 | 5 | 0.25 | 8 | 7 |
Segment: 7 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Segment: 8 | 2 | 0.1 | 1 | 0.1 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 |
Segment: 9 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 |
Segment: 10 | 5 | 0.3 | 3 | 0.3 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 |
Totals: | 195 | 5.3 | 84 | 4.229 | 22 | 1.071 | 55 | 34 |
Ballot Pool Members
Segment | Organization | Voter | Designated Proxy | Ballot | NERC Memo |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
3 | Con Ed - Consolidated Edison Co. of New York | Peter Yost | Abstain | N/A | |
3 | Dominion - Dominion Resources, Inc. | Connie Schroeder | Abstain | N/A | |
5 | Dairyland Power Cooperative | Tommy Drea | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | Ameren - Ameren Services | David Jendras | Abstain | N/A | |
3 | Georgia System Operations Corporation | Scott McGough | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | PSEG - PSEG Energy Resources and Trade LLC | Luiggi Beretta | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
4 | MGE Energy - Madison Gas and Electric Co. | Joseph DePoorter | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Ameren - Ameren Missouri | Sam Dwyer | Abstain | N/A | |
6 | Dominion - Dominion Resources, Inc. | Sean Bodkin | Abstain | N/A | |
6 | Ameren - Ameren Services | Robert Quinlivan | Abstain | N/A | |
1 | Dominion - Dominion Virginia Power | Candace Marshall | Abstain | N/A | |
2 | Southwest Power Pool, Inc. (RTO) | Charles Yeung | Affirmative | N/A | |
1 | Ameren - Ameren Services | Eric Scott | Abstain | N/A | |
2 | Independent Electricity System Operator | Leonard Kula | Affirmative | N/A | |
2 | PJM Interconnection, L.L.C. | Mark Holman | Abstain | N/A | |
1 | Omaha Public Power District | Doug Peterchuck | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Brazos Electric Power Cooperative, Inc. | Shari Heino | Abstain | N/A | |
1 | Tri-State G and T Association, Inc. | Kjersti Drott | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
3 | Sempra - San Diego Gas and Electric | Bridget Silvia | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | Basin Electric Power Cooperative | Jeremy Voll | Affirmative | N/A | |
10 | SERC Reliability Corporation | Dave Krueger | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Edison International - Southern California Edison Company | Neil Shockey | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | Basin Electric Power Cooperative | Jerry Horner | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | Tennessee Valley Authority | Ian Grant | Abstain | N/A | |
5 | Northern California Power Agency | Marty Hostler | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
6 | NiSource - Northern Indiana Public Service Co. | Joe O'Brien | Abstain | N/A | |
1 | SaskPower | Wayne Guttormson | Abstain | N/A | |
10 | Midwest Reliability Organization | William Steiner | None | N/A | |
3 | Duke Energy | Lee Schuster | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | OGE Energy - Oklahoma Gas and Electric Co. | Sing Tay | Abstain | N/A | |
6 | Northern California Power Agency | Dennis Sismaet | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
8 | David Kiguel | David Kiguel | Affirmative | N/A | |
4 | Northern California Power Agency | Marty Hostler | None | N/A | |
5 | Choctaw Generation Limited Partnership, LLLP | Rob Watson | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | Salt River Project | Bobby Olsen | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
1 | Southern Company - Southern Company Services, Inc. | Matt Carden | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | Southern Company - Alabama Power Company | Joel Dembowski | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | Southern Company - Southern Company Generation | Ron Carlsen | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Black Hills Corporation | Derek Silbaugh | None | N/A | |
2 | Midcontinent ISO, Inc. | Bobbi Welch | Abstain | N/A | |
5 | Southern Company - Southern Company Generation | William D. Shultz | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Salt River Project | Kevin Nielsen | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
6 | Black Hills Corporation | Claudine Bates | None | N/A | |
1 | APS - Arizona Public Service Co. | Daniela Atanasovski | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | APS - Arizona Public Service Co. | Kelsi Rigby | Affirmative | N/A | |
10 | New York State Reliability Council | ALAN ADAMSON | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Ontario Power Generation Inc. | Constantin Chitescu | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | Austin Energy | W. Dwayne Preston | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Cowlitz County PUD | Deanna Carlson | Abstain | N/A | |
5 | Dominion - Dominion Resources, Inc. | Rachel Snead | Abstain | N/A | |
1 | Tennessee Valley Authority | Gabe Kurtz | Abstain | N/A | |
4 | Seminole Electric Cooperative, Inc. | Jonathan Robbins | Abstain | N/A | |
3 | Ocala Utility Services | Neville Bowen | None | N/A | |
1 | New York Power Authority | Salvatore Spagnolo | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | Nebraska Public Power District | Tony Eddleman | Abstain | N/A | |
3 | Avista - Avista Corporation | Scott Kinney | None | N/A | |
3 | Owensboro Municipal Utilities | Thomas Lyons | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | Public Utility District No. 2 of Grant County, Washington | LeRoy Patterson | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
3 | New York Power Authority | David Rivera | Affirmative | N/A | |
10 | Northeast Power Coordinating Council | Guy V. Zito | Affirmative | N/A | |
9 | Commonwealth of Massachusetts Department of Public Utilities | Donald Nelson | Abstain | N/A | |
6 | New York Power Authority | Erick Barrios | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | APS - Arizona Public Service Co. | Chinedu Ochonogor | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Avista - Avista Corporation | Glen Farmer | None | N/A | |
6 | Con Ed - Consolidated Edison Co. of New York | Christopher Overberg | Abstain | N/A | |
4 | City Utilities of Springfield, Missouri | John Allen | Abstain | N/A | |
5 | Con Ed - Consolidated Edison Co. of New York | William Winters | Abstain | N/A | |
1 | City Utilities of Springfield, Missouri | Michael Bowman | Abstain | N/A | |
1 | Con Ed - Consolidated Edison Co. of New York | Dermot Smyth | Abstain | N/A | |
3 | City Utilities of Springfield, Missouri | Scott Williams | Abstain | N/A | |
3 | APS - Arizona Public Service Co. | Vivian Moser | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Lincoln Electric System | Kayleigh Wilkerson | Abstain | N/A | |
6 | Berkshire Hathaway - PacifiCorp | Sandra Shaffer | Affirmative | N/A | |
1 | National Grid USA | Michael Jones | Abstain | N/A | |
5 | Entergy | Jamie Prater | Abstain | N/A | |
5 | Sempra - San Diego Gas and Electric | Jennifer Wright | Affirmative | N/A | |
1 | Sempra - San Diego Gas and Electric | Mo Derbas | Affirmative | N/A | |
1 | Austin Energy | Thomas Standifur | Affirmative | N/A | |
4 | Austin Energy | Jun Hua | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Massachusetts Municipal Wholesale Electric Company | Anthony Stevens | Abstain | N/A | |
4 | Alliant Energy Corporation Services, Inc. | Larry Heckert | Abstain | N/A | |
3 | Edison International - Southern California Edison Company | Romel Aquino | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | FirstEnergy - FirstEnergy Corporation | Aaron Ghodooshim | None | N/A | |
1 | NiSource - Northern Indiana Public Service Co. | Steve Toosevich | Abstain | N/A | |
5 | Austin Energy | Lisa Martin | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | Los Angeles Department of Water and Power | Anton Vu | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Talen Generation, LLC | Donald Lock | None | N/A | |
6 | Talen Energy Marketing, LLC | Jennifer Hohenshilt | None | N/A | |
3 | National Grid USA | Brian Shanahan | Abstain | N/A | |
1 | Los Angeles Department of Water and Power | faranak sarbaz | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | NiSource - Northern Indiana Public Service Co. | Dmitriy Bazylyuk | Abstain | N/A | |
6 | Lincoln Electric System | Eric Ruskamp | Abstain | N/A | |
1 | Lincoln Electric System | Danny Pudenz | Abstain | N/A | |
10 | Western Electricity Coordinating Council | Steven Rueckert | None | N/A | |
1 | Tacoma Public Utilities (Tacoma, WA) | John Merrell | Jennie Wike | Negative | Comments Submitted |
6 | PPL - Louisville Gas and Electric Co. | Linn Oelker | None | N/A | |
1 | Hydro-Qu?bec TransEnergie | Nicolas Turcotte | Affirmative | N/A | |
1 | Dairyland Power Cooperative | Renee Leidel | Affirmative | N/A | |
1 | Lakeland Electric | Larry Watt | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | Lakeland Electric | Paul Shipps | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | CMS Energy - Consumers Energy Company | David Greyerbiehl | None | N/A | |
1 | Salt River Project | Chris Hofmann | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
5 | Associated Electric Cooperative, Inc. | Chuck Booth | None | N/A | |
1 | U.S. Bureau of Reclamation | Richard Jackson | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
5 | Platte River Power Authority | Tyson Archie | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Public Utility District No. 1 of Chelan County | Meaghan Connell | Affirmative | N/A | |
1 | Public Utility District No. 1 of Chelan County | Ginette Lacasse | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | Salt River Project | Zack Heim | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
3 | Public Utility District No. 1 of Chelan County | Joyce Gundry | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | Lincoln Electric System | Angelica Valencia | None | N/A | |
5 | New York Power Authority | Shivaz Chopra | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | NiSource - Northern Indiana Public Service Co. | Kathryn Tackett | Abstain | N/A | |
1 | Seminole Electric Cooperative, Inc. | Bret Galbraith | Abstain | N/A | |
1 | NB Power Corporation | Nurul Abser | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | Florida Municipal Power Pool | Aaron Casto | None | N/A | |
5 | Omaha Public Power District | Mahmood Safi | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Duke Energy | Dale Goodwine | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | Public Utility District No. 1 of Chelan County | Davis Jelusich | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | Sacramento Municipal Utility District | Jamie Cutlip | Joe Tarantino | Affirmative | N/A |
3 | Sacramento Municipal Utility District | Nicole Looney | Joe Tarantino | Affirmative | N/A |
5 | Herb Schrayshuen | Herb Schrayshuen | Affirmative | N/A | |
1 | Sacramento Municipal Utility District | Arthur Starkovich | Joe Tarantino | Affirmative | N/A |
5 | Boise-Kuna Irrigation District - Lucky Peak Power Plant Project | Mike Kukla | None | N/A | |
3 | Tacoma Public Utilities (Tacoma, WA) | Marc Donaldson | Jennie Wike | Negative | Comments Submitted |
1 | OGE Energy - Oklahoma Gas and Electric Co. | Terri Pyle | Abstain | N/A | |
3 | OGE Energy - Oklahoma Gas and Electric Co. | Donald Hargrove | Abstain | N/A | |
4 | Seattle City Light | Hao Li | None | N/A | |
3 | Black Hills Corporation | Josh Combs | None | N/A | |
4 | Tacoma Public Utilities (Tacoma, WA) | Hien Ho | Jennie Wike | Negative | Comments Submitted |
1 | Seattle City Light | Pawel Krupa | Affirmative | N/A | |
1 | Black Hills Corporation | Micah Runner | None | N/A | |
6 | Edison International - Southern California Edison Company | Kenya Streeter | None | N/A | |
6 | Tacoma Public Utilities (Tacoma, WA) | Terry Gifford | Jennie Wike | Negative | Comments Submitted |
3 | Portland General Electric Co. | Adam Menendez | None | N/A | |
6 | Portland General Electric Co. | Daniel Mason | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Seattle City Light | Faz Kasraie | None | N/A | |
4 | Sacramento Municipal Utility District | Beth Tincher | Joe Tarantino | Affirmative | N/A |
5 | Sacramento Municipal Utility District | Nicole Goi | Joe Tarantino | Affirmative | N/A |
1 | Portland General Electric Co. | Angela Gaines | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | Los Angeles Department of Water and Power | Tony Skourtas | Affirmative | N/A | |
1 | Glencoe Light and Power Commission | Terry Volkmann | None | N/A | |
5 | National Grid USA | Elizabeth Spivak | None | N/A | |
5 | Los Angeles Department of Water and Power | Glenn Barry | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | Berkshire Hathaway Energy - MidAmerican Energy Co. | Darnez Gresham | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | Duke Energy | Greg Cecil | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | Lakeland Electric | Patricia Boody | Abstain | N/A | |
2 | California ISO | Jamie Johnson | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | Platte River Power Authority | Sabrina Martz | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | Platte River Power Authority | Wade Kiess | Affirmative | N/A | |
1 | Platte River Power Authority | Matt Thompson | Affirmative | N/A | |
8 | Florida Reliability Coordinating Council – Member Services Division | Vince Ordax | Abstain | N/A | |
5 | Tacoma Public Utilities (Tacoma, WA) | Ozan Ferrin | Jennie Wike | Negative | Comments Submitted |
5 | OGE Energy - Oklahoma Gas and Electric Co. | Patrick Wells | Abstain | N/A | |
1 | Duke Energy | Laura Lee | Affirmative | N/A | |
4 | Utility Services, Inc. | Brian Evans-Mongeon | None | N/A | |
3 | DTE Energy - Detroit Edison Company | Karie Barczak | None | N/A | |
1 | Santee Cooper | Chris Wagner | Abstain | N/A | |
3 | Santee Cooper | James Poston | Abstain | N/A | |
5 | Santee Cooper | Tommy Curtis | Abstain | N/A | |
6 | Santee Cooper | Michael Brown | Abstain | N/A | |
1 | Western Area Power Administration | sean erickson | Abstain | N/A | |
1 | Public Utility District No. 1 of Pend Oreille County | Kevin Conway | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Tri-State G and T Association, Inc. | Ryan Walter | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
1 | JEA | Joe McClung | Affirmative | N/A | |
1 | International Transmission Company Holdings Corporation | Michael Moltane | Abstain | N/A | |
1 | Exelon | Daniel Gacek | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | Exelon | Kinte Whitehead | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Exelon | Cynthia Lee | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | Exelon | Becky Webb | Affirmative | N/A | |
1 | Long Island Power Authority | Robert Ganley | Abstain | N/A | |
5 | Bonneville Power Administration | Scott Winner | None | N/A | |
6 | Seattle City Light | Brian Belger | None | N/A | |
1 | NextEra Energy - Florida Power and Light Co. | Silvia Mitchell | None | N/A | |
3 | Tri-State G and T Association, Inc. | Janelle Marriott Gill | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
1 | CMS Energy - Consumers Energy Company | Donald Lynd | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
6 | Entergy | Julie Hall | None | N/A | |
1 | Nebraska Public Power District | Jamison Cawley | Affirmative | N/A | |
3 | PPL - Louisville Gas and Electric Co. | James Frank | None | N/A | |
4 | CMS Energy - Consumers Energy Company | Dwayne Parker | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
3 | CMS Energy - Consumers Energy Company | Karl Blaszkowski | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
5 | PPL - Louisville Gas and Electric Co. | JULIE HOSTRANDER | None | N/A | |
1 | PPL Electric Utilities Corporation | Michelle Longo | None | N/A | |
3 | Snohomish County PUD No. 1 | Holly Chaney | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Great River Energy | Jacalynn Bentz | Affirmative | N/A | |
4 | Public Utility District No. 1 of Snohomish County | John Martinsen | Affirmative | N/A | |
6 | Snohomish County PUD No. 1 | John Liang | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | Public Utility District No. 1 of Snohomish County | Sam Nietfeld | Affirmative | N/A | |
1 | BC Hydro and Power Authority | Adrian Andreoiu | Abstain | N/A | |
6 | Great River Energy | Donna Stephenson | Affirmative | N/A | |
5 | BC Hydro and Power Authority | Helen Hamilton Harding | Abstain | N/A | |
3 | BC Hydro and Power Authority | Hootan Jarollahi | Abstain | N/A | |
6 | Powerex Corporation | Gordon Dobson-Mack | Abstain | N/A | |
3 | Northern California Power Agency | Michael Whitney | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
5 | U.S. Bureau of Reclamation | Wendy Kalidass | Negative | Comments Submitted | |
1 | GridLiance Holdco, LP | Randy Cleland | Affirmative | N/A |